Jordan Neely’s death on NYC subway: A history of white citizens and racial homicide on public transportation

On a New York City subway carriage, on May 1, 2023, Jordan Neely, a 30-year-old homeless African American man, was killed after Daniel Penny, 24, restrained Neely in a chokehold that lasted almost six minutes.

Neely, who suffered with drug addiction and had a history of mental illness, boarded the train at the Second Avenue station after which he allegedly became agitated, threatening and screaming at passengers. Penny, a white United States Marine Corps veteran, approached Neely from behind and placed him in a chokehold. Penny later told the court that he believed Neely posed a real and dangerous threat to fellow commuters. He alleged he was trying to restrain him until police arrived.

A New York City medical examiner ruled that Neely died from compression to his neck resulting from the chokehold.

The manslaughter case against Penny, was dismissed after the jury deadlocked and he was acquitted on the remaining charge of criminally negligent homicide. Penny was found not guilty in Neely’s death on December 9, 2024. A wrongful death suit by Neely’s father remains pending as of December 20, 2024.

Neely's Death in Historical Perspective

Neely’s tragic death at the hands of a private citizen — acting out of a sense of public duty or not — is a familiar story, one told many times in the Burnham-Nobles Digital Archive in the cases of racially-motivated homicide on public conveyances in the Jim Crow South.

Throughout the twentieth century, white vigilantism was a real and threat to African Americans in public spaces. The archive contains many cases in which private citizens felt empowered to violently police Black behavior, some acting with probable cause but many without.

Henry Williams, a 23-year-old African American man, boarded a bus on his way back to Brookley Field in Mobile, Alabama, on August 15, 1942. Williams, who was actively serving in the U.S. Army at the time, confronted the white bus driver when he stopped to talk with another bus service employee. Williams was reportedly anxious about getting back to the base and did not want to return late.

A fight ensued between Williams and the driver. As Williams turned to disembark, the driver shot him.

The NAACP responded to Williams’ killing with a bus boycott that resulted in the bus company disarming all its drivers, for a brief time. The bus company did not fire the driver.

On July 8, 1944, Booker T. Spicely, an army private at Camp Butner near Durham, North Carolina, was murdered after refusing to give up his seat on a bus. Following a disagreement, bus driver Herman Lee Council shot Spicely twice in the chest as the Black solider was disembarking the bus. Council left Spicely, who had served his country in World War II, to die in the street while he continued servicing his customary route.

Phinizy William Summerour, 41, was riding a Pine-Forrest city bus in Atlanta, Georgia, when he was shot and killed on November 28, 1945. Allegedly, Summerour argued with a white passenger, Arthur Freiberg, about smoking on the bus. Freiberg responded by shooting Summerour to death.

After a lengthy preliminary hearing, Frieberg was held on a charge of manslaughter and bound over for a Grand Jury investigation. The grand jury released Freiberg without charge and no accountability found for Summerour’s death. Friedburg argued to the members of the jury that Summerour was about to pull a gun on him and so he shot him in self-defense. It was later proved that Summerour was unarmed.

A year later, in September 1946, Berry Branch Sr. was riding a bus in Houston, Texas, when he found himself in the middle of an argument between the bus driver and a 17-year-old boy. They were allegedly quarrelling about the teenager’s bus fare. Branch, a 60-year-old barbershop owner, tried to mediate the disagreement but was shot and killed by the white bus driver.

Branch’s death sparked a broad-based campaign to disarm bus drivers. This activism garnered support from civil rights groups, as well as other interracial and union organizers. But their efforts were attacked and discredited as communist activities.

News article from the Birmingham News regarding the shooting of Henry Williams: August 16, 1942. Courtesy of the Burnham-Nobles Digital Archive.
News article from the Birmingham News regarding the shooting of Henry Williams: August 16, 1942. Courtesy of the Burnham-Nobles Digital Archive.
News article from the Houston informer about the shooting of Berry Branch: September 21, 1946. Courtesy of the Burnham-Nobles Digital Archive.
News article from the Houston informer about the shooting of Berry Branch: September 21, 1946. Courtesy of the Burnham-Nobles Digital Archive.

Motive notwithstanding, there is ample precedent for white private citizens taking on the role of law enforcement, without deputization, and often without provocation, particularly on public conveyances. The circumstances in these cases may vary from those surrounding Neely’s tragic death but, examined through this historical lens, Neely’s death can be viewed as both avoidable and foreseeable.

Join our mailing list

Receive the latest news about CRRJ's work, events and programs.


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive email communications from The Civil Rights and Restorative Justice Project https://crrj.org. You can unsubscribe any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe link found at the bottom of every email. Serviced by Constant Contact.
to top